On this page

Quick answer

For most baking and cooking, use ¾ cup unsalted vegetable oil for every 1 cup butter. For sautéing, use 1 tablespoon oil for 2 tablespoons butter. Oil cannot cream air into flour or butter a filling, so lower the baking temperature by 25°F if the recipe gives one.

At a glance

Time
No prep
Difficulty
Easy
You'll need
A measured substitute, the original butter amount, and measuring cups or a scale
Best option
Unsalted vegetable oil at 3/4 cup per 1 cup butter
Works for
Cakes, muffins, quick breads, pancakes, and sautéing
Not covered
Whipped toppings, laminated doughs, and butter-flavored frostings

What does butter do in a recipe?

Butter does more than add fat. It brings richness, a clear dairy note, and a little moisture, while helping the food brown. In cakes and cookies, fat also tenderizes the crumb by coating the flour and limiting gluten development. When softened butter is beaten with sugar, it holds small air pockets that help the batter rise. That is why a creaming step cannot be replaced by pouring in any liquid fat.

No single substitute provides all of those functions at once. An oil replaces fat and can keep a baked crumb tender, but it adds no dairy flavor or extra moisture and cannot hold air through creaming. Yogurt brings fat, water, protein, and acidity, so it changes both flavor and structure. Applesauce adds moisture but little fat. Choose a swap by the job butter is doing in that recipe, not by matching the measuring cup alone.

Before you swap

Before changing anything, check how much butter the recipe uses and what it is expected to do. A tablespoon in a pan sauce is not the same decision as a cup in a layer cake.

  1. Measure the role, not just the amount. Note whether the butter is melted, softened, browned, creamed, or used as a filling. If it is creamed or layered into dough, its solid fat and structure matter.
  2. Decide whether butter is the star. In a plain pound cake, mild fat may work well. In shortbread, a butter cookie, or a brown-butter sauce, the flavor and aroma are part of the recipe.
  3. Identify the cooking method. Pan cooking needs usable fat. Baking depends on how fat interacts with flour, sugar, leavening, and the oven.
  4. Plan for moisture and temperature. If the replacement contains water, such as yogurt or applesauce, reduce another liquid. For an oil swap in a baked recipe, lower the oven by 25°F and start checking early.

Before converting a full recipe, make one small test portion. You can check changes in spread, moisture, browning, and texture without rebuilding the whole batch.

Option 1 Unsalted vegetable oil

Why it works

Unsalted vegetable oil supplies fat without a strong flavor. It works in many batters and keeps fat evenly distributed through the mixture. You lose butter’s dairy aroma, its small amount of water, and the structure it creates when creamed with sugar.

Exact ratio

For baking, use 3/4 cup oil for every 1 cup butter. That is 2 tablespoons oil for every 3 tablespoons butter. For sautéing or pan-cooking, start with 1 tablespoon oil for every 2 tablespoons butter and add more only if the food needs it.

How to adjust

Use it in cakes, muffins, quick breads, pancakes, and savory batters where dairy flavor is not the point. Oil makes cookies with crisp edges and a tender, often slightly cakier center. If the recipe gives an oven temperature, lower it by 25°F and begin checking the bake 5–10 minutes early. Do not expect the same rise from creaming; if the recipe depends on that structure, choose a formula written for oil instead.

Where it works

This is the most flexible all-around oil swap, especially for cakes and cookies. It is a poor match for whipped buttercream, laminated pastry, or any recipe built around browned-butter flavor. Choose unsalted so it does not make a savory dish unexpectedly salty.

Option 2 Extra-virgin olive oil

Why it works

Extra-virgin olive oil provides fat plus a green, fruity, sometimes peppery note. That note can complement bread, vegetables, pasta, and Mediterranean-style dishes. In a plain cake or cookie, it becomes a flavor of its own rather than a neutral replacement.

Exact ratio

Use 3/4 cup olive oil for every 1 cup butter. For sautéing, start with 1 tablespoon for every 2 tablespoons butter. If you want some of olive oil’s character without letting it dominate, use 1/2 cup olive oil plus 1/4 cup neutral oil for each 1 cup butter; the total remains 3/4 cup.

How to adjust

Use it in roasted vegetables, sautéed foods, pasta sauces, focaccia, savory breads, and some cookies. For the same reason, lower the oven by 25°F in oil-based baking and check 5–10 minutes early. If the recipe uses softened butter for creaming or layering, the dough will not behave in the same way. A mixed oil blend can soften the olive flavor without changing the measured fat volume.

Where it works

Choose it when you want olive flavor as part of the dish. It does not suit classic butter cookies, plain buttercream, or shortbread unless that flavor is intentional. It also cannot reproduce the aroma of browned butter.

Option 3 Solid coconut oil

Why it works

Solid coconut oil is a fat you can beat with sugar, so it can take the place of butter in some doughs. Refined coconut oil has little coconut aroma; unrefined coconut oil has a strong one. It contains less water than butter, so it does not duplicate butter’s moisture contribution.

Exact ratio

Use 1 cup coconut oil for every 1 cup butter, a 1:1 swap by volume. If it is already melted, let it cool until it is soft enough to scoop and measure accurately before mixing. For a creaming step, beat the measured oil with the sugar just as you would butter.

How to adjust

Coconut oil works in many cookies, muffins, quick breads, and snack cakes. For cookies, it often spreads more than butter, so chill shaped dough for 20–30 minutes if the pans need it. Watch the first bake closely because both spread and browning can differ. Do not reduce the recipe’s liquid automatically; judge the dough after mixing. If the dough is sticky, chill it rather than adding more flour, which can make the finished crumb dry.

Where it works

Choose refined coconut oil when you want a solid-fat swap without a coconut note. Unrefined oil suits recipes that intentionally want coconut flavor. It is a poor choice for plain buttercream, delicate shortbread, or flaky pastry, and it does not provide butter’s dairy aroma.

Option 4 Plain yogurt or sour cream

Why it works

Plain yogurt or sour cream brings fat, water, protein, and a little acidity. Those components can make a cake crumb moist and tender, but they also change the structure. This is not a fat-for-fat replacement for butter, and it cannot be creamed into air.

Exact ratio

Replace each 1/4 cup, or 4 tablespoons, of butter with 1/4 cup, or 4 tablespoons, of full-fat plain yogurt or sour cream. This is a 1:1 volume swap at that amount. Because the replacement is not equivalent in fat, reduce another liquid in the recipe by 1 tablespoon for every 1/4 cup of yogurt or sour cream you add.

How to adjust

Mix the yogurt or sour cream with the dry ingredients, then add the remaining wet ingredients. Keep the original leavening amount for the first test; extra acid can change how a soda-based batter rises. Lower the oven by 25°F and start checking 5–10 minutes early. If the batter is loose, reduce milk or other liquid before reducing the dairy. Use plain, unsweetened dairy so the flavor change comes only from the swap.

Where it works

Best for moist yellow cakes, fruit muffins, and quick breads where a soft crumb is acceptable. Avoid butter cookies, flaky pastry, pie crust, and whipped frostings, which depend on butter’s solid fat and flavor. It contains milk, so it is not a choice for a milk-free diet.

Option 5 Avocado oil

Why it works

Avocado oil is a mild-tasting liquid fat. It can handle higher pan-cooking temperatures than butter without adding a strong vegetable or fruit note. Like every oil, it supplies fat but no butter aroma, and it cannot build volume through creaming.

Exact ratio

Use 3/4 cup avocado oil for every 1 cup butter in a batter. For sautéing, start with 1 tablespoon avocado oil for every 2 tablespoons butter. Measure it like any other oil; do not use a 1:1 volume swap.

How to adjust

Use it in cakes, muffins, pancakes, and savory cooking when you want a neutral fat but not a dairy flavor. Cookies made with it may spread because the fat stays liquid, so a recipe designed for shortening or solid fat is usually a better match. If the recipe gives a baking temperature, lower it by 25°F and check early.

Where it works

Choose avocado oil when the dish needs fat for cooking but does not depend on butter flavor. It is a poor match for classic butter cookies, buttercream, or a sauce whose character comes from browned butter. A mild olive oil can also fill this role when you want a slightly fruitier note.

Option 6 Unsweetened applesauce

Why it works

Unsweetened applesauce contributes moisture and fruit sugars, along with pectin that can help a batter hold together. It replaces some of butter’s fat rather than matching its solid-fat structure, so the result is usually softer and cakier, not short and crumbly.

Exact ratio

Use 1/2 cup unsweetened applesauce for every 1 cup butter. That is 2 tablespoons applesauce for every 4 tablespoons butter. Reduce another liquid in the recipe by 1–2 tablespoons for each 1/2 cup applesauce, starting with 1 tablespoon and adding more only if the batter is loose.

How to adjust

Stir the applesauce into the dry ingredients before adding the rest of the liquid. It works best in muffins, quick breads, brownies, and soft cookies. It can make cookies spread more and lose their crisp edges, so watch the first pan closely. Homemade applesauce varies in moisture; weigh or measure it rather than estimating from the jar.

Where it works

Choose unsweetened applesauce for a fruit-forward bake that does not need a buttery aroma. It is a poor fit for crisp cookies, shortbread, biscuits, pie crust, and pastry, where fat structure is essential. It can also weaken a cake’s structure if the batter is overmixed, so stop mixing once the dry and wet ingredients are just combined.

Option 7 Mashed banana

Why it works

Mashed banana adds moisture, starch, sweetness, and banana flavor. It is useful when banana suits the dish, but it changes both sweetness and texture. A very ripe banana contributes more liquid and sweetness than a just-ripe one.

Exact ratio

Use 1/2 cup mashed banana for every 1 cup butter, measured after peeling. Reduce the recipe’s sugar by 1–2 tablespoons for each 1/2 cup banana added, beginning with the smaller reduction and adjusting to taste. Mash until smooth, and measure by volume rather than using a “one banana” shortcut, because banana size and moisture vary.

How to adjust

Use it in banana bread, banana muffins, pancakes, and quick breads. If the recipe already contains banana, count the added banana as part of the wet ingredients instead of adding the full swap on top. Reduce sugar and other liquid before changing the butter, because banana affects both.

Where it works

Choose banana when its flavor belongs in the recipe. It is not a good match for plain butter cookies, frosting, flaky pastry, or shortbread. It can make a cookie or brownie wetter and cakier, so use it only when that texture suits the result.

Substitutes compared

Substitute Ratio Best for How the flavor changes
Unsalted vegetable oil 3/4 cup per 1 cup butter Cakes, muffins, quick breads, pancakes, and sautéing Neutral; loses butter aroma and creaming structure
Extra-virgin olive oil 3/4 cup per 1 cup butter Savory breads, pasta, and roasted vegetables Fruity and sometimes peppery
Plain yogurt or sour cream 1/4 cup per 1/4 cup butter; reduce other liquid by 1 tablespoon Moist cakes, muffins, and quick breads Tangy and less buttery; adds moisture
Solid coconut oil 1 cup per 1 cup butter Cookies, muffins, and snack cakes Little aroma when refined; a coconut note when unrefined
Avocado oil 3/4 cup per 1 cup butter Cakes, muffins, pancakes, and pan cooking Mild; no butter aroma
Unsweetened applesauce 1/2 cup per 1 cup butter; reduce other liquid by 1–2 tablespoons Muffins, quick breads, brownies, and soft cookies Fruit sweetness and a soft, cakier texture
Mashed banana 1/2 cup per 1 cup butter; reduce sugar by 1–2 tablespoons Banana bread, muffins, and pancakes Sweet, fruity, and moist; no butter aroma

When not to substitute

  • Laminated and flaky doughs. Puff pastry and croissants depend on butter layers for lift and flake. Most oils or moist purees cannot reproduce that structure.
  • Recipes built around butter flavor. Brown butter, beurre blanc, compound butter, and classic buttercream rely on aroma, flavor, or solid fat that a general swap will not match.
  • Precise pastry and shortbread formulas. Pie crust, biscuits, and shortbread need a specific amount of solid fat. An equal-volume oil swap can make them greasy or crumbly.
  • Whipped toppings that require solid fat. Some buttercreams and cream fillings are whipped around chilled butter. Liquid oil cannot hold the same structure.
  • Restrictions that exclude dairy. Yogurt and sour cream contain milk. If the recipe must be milk-free, check every substitute’s ingredient list and the cook’s cross-contact requirements rather than assuming a swap is suitable.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Swapping oil one-for-one. Using 1 cup oil for 1 cup butter adds too much fat to many batters. For neutral oils, start at 3/4 cup per cup butter.
  • Ignoring the liquid already in the recipe. Yogurt, sour cream, applesauce, and banana bring moisture. Reduce another liquid, and change the fat only after the batter’s consistency is right.
  • Expecting creaming from a liquid. Beating oil or melted butter with sugar does not trap air the way softened butter does. Use a formula designed for the substitute if the recipe’s rise depends on creaming.
  • Choosing flavor before function. Extra-virgin olive oil is useful in savory cooking but can dominate a plain cookie. Check the dish before deciding which fat fits.
  • Changing too many things at once. Do not swap the fat, add extra liquid, and alter the leavening in the same test. Adjust one variable at a time so you can see what changed.

How to store it so you have it next time

  • Butter: Wrap it tightly and refrigerate at 40°F or below; use within about 3–4 months. Freeze at 0°F for longer storage, then thaw only the portion you need.
  • Yogurt or sour cream: Keep it sealed and refrigerated at 40°F or below; use within about 1–2 weeks. Freeze it promptly if you will not use it within that window.
  • Applesauce and mashed banana: Refrigerate covered portions within 2 hours and use within about 3–4 days, or freeze them in usable portions.
  • Opening oils: Store the bottle sealed in a cool, dark cabinet and use within about 1 year, or sooner if the label says so. Throw it out if it smells stale or has particles.

Storage windows vary by food and package. Check the USDA FoodKeeper app for the specific product and follow its limit when it is shorter than the ranges above.

Keep your refrigerator at 40°F or below. Refrigerate perishable batters and leftovers within 2 hours, and reheat leftovers to 165°F. If butter or a dairy substitute develops mold, an off smell, or an unusual texture, throw it out.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best substitute for butter in baking?

Unsalted vegetable oil is the most flexible option for cakes, muffins, and quick breads. Use 3/4 cup for every 1 cup butter, and lower the oven temperature by 25°F when the recipe gives one. It changes the flavor and creaming structure, so it is not a straight 1:1 swap.

Can I use olive oil instead of butter in cookies?

Yes, but expect a fruitier cookie with a softer, cakier center. Use 3/4 cup olive oil for every 1 cup butter, then lower the oven temperature by 25°F and check the cookies 5–10 minutes early. Use a mild oil instead if you want the butter flavor to stay subtle.

Is coconut oil a direct substitute for butter?

Refined coconut oil can be used at a 1:1 volume ratio, but it is softer and has less water than butter. Measure it accurately and chill the dough briefly if cookies spread too much. It will not reproduce a clear butter flavor, and unrefined oil adds a distinct coconut taste.

Can yogurt or sour cream replace butter in cake?

You can use full-fat plain yogurt or sour cream in moist cakes and quick breads. Replace each 1/4 cup butter with 1/4 cup yogurt and reduce the recipe's other liquid by 1 tablespoon. Do not use this swap for cookies, pastry, or frosting that depends on solid butter.

Can I use applesauce or banana instead of butter?

Unsweetened applesauce works in muffins, quick breads, brownies, and soft cookies. Use 1/2 cup for every 1 cup butter and reduce other liquid by 1–2 tablespoons; mashed banana works well in banana breads and pancakes. Neither is a good match for crisp cookies, pie crust, or flaky pastry.

How should I store butter and the substitutes?

Keep butter wrapped and refrigerated at 40°F or below for about 3–4 months, or freeze it at 0°F for longer. Keep yogurt or sour cream refrigerated for about 1–2 weeks, and refrigerate applesauce or mashed banana for about 3–4 days; freeze portions you will not use promptly. Check the USDA FoodKeeper app for product-specific limits, and throw anything out if it has mold, a bad smell, or an unusual texture.

What this guide is based on

  • Manufacturer use-and-care and support documentation for the device

Revision history

  1. Updated and re-checked against sources.
  2. First published.

Did this fix it?

Mixtvnowcom.org editors Editorial team

The Mixtvnowcom.org editors write and check every guide on the site against the manufacturer instructions and official sources it lists, and keep each guide's revision history up to date.

More guides from the editors