On this page
Quick answer
For most baking, use unsalted butter, coconut oil, or neutral vegetable oil at 1:1 by volume: 1 cup for 1 cup of shortening. Butter adds dairy flavor, coconut oil adds a slight coconut note, and plain oil keeps the flavor neutral. For pie crust, use 1/2 cup butter plus 1/2 cup oil for each 1 cup of shortening.
At a glance
- Time
- No prep
- Difficulty
- Easy
- You'll need
- Measuring cup, butter, coconut oil, or neutral oil
- Best option
- Unsalted butter for most cakes and cookies
- Works for
- Cakes, cookies, muffins, biscuits, and pie crust
- Not covered
- Puff pastry, laminated dough, and candy-making
What does shortening do in a recipe?
Shortening is a solid cooking fat, usually made from refined vegetable oils, although formulas differ by product. Its main jobs are to add fat, tenderize the crumb, and keep baked goods from tasting dry. In pie dough, biscuits, and laminated pastry, solid fat also leaves small spaces between layers as it melts during baking. That effect depends on the fat staying solid or firm while the dough is made.
Shortening usually contains almost no water, so it does not behave exactly like butter. Butter adds dairy flavor and browning from its milk solids, and it creates a different balance of tenderness and flakiness. Liquid oil keeps the fat but contributes less structure during creaming. Measure a replacement by volume unless the recipe gives a weight, and choose the substitute by function: solid fat for flaky layers, liquid fat for moist cakes, or a blend when neither behaves exactly enough.
Before you swap
Read the whole recipe before choosing a fat. A measured swap can solve the problem; changing the flour, sugar, leavening, or temperature at the same time makes the result harder to understand.
- Amount: Note whether the fat is a major flavor or a background fat, and whether the recipe measures it in cups, tablespoons, ounces, or grams. Use the same volume measure for the swap unless the recipe gives a weight.
- Job: Decide whether shortening is creaming fat, tenderizing fat, a flaky-layer fat, pan grease, or frying fat. A background role is easier to replace than a flavor the recipe is designed to showcase.
- Flavor: Check the label for plain, butter-flavored, or other specialty shortening. Butter, lard, ghee, and flavored olive oil each add a distinct note; refined coconut oil and neutral vegetable oil are quieter choices.
- Form and heat: Check whether the recipe wants solid, softened, or melted fat, and whether the food is mixed raw or cooked. Butter must be softened for creaming, liquid oil cannot be creamed, and a pan-greasing spray is not a cup-for-cup ingredient.
Tip: Make the first change to the fat only. Keep the flour, sugar, leavening, and baking temperature the same so you can judge the swap accurately.
Option 1 Unsalted butter
Why it works: Butter supplies the fat that tenderizes crumbs and, in pie dough and biscuits, creates flaky layers. It is the most useful all-around swap, but its water and milk solids make it more flavorful and less shortening-like than the original.
Ratio: Use 1 cup, or 16 tablespoons, of unsalted butter for every 1 cup of shortening. That means 8 tablespoons for 1/2 cup shortening. If a package measures shortening by the stick, check its stated cup equivalent rather than assuming.
How to adjust: Soften butter to room temperature for a creamed batter. Melt and cool it only when the recipe calls for melted butter or melted shortening. Cookies usually spread more and brown faster, so chill the dough if the finished batch looks greasy. Use unsalted butter unless you adjust the recipe’s salt.
Best for: Cakes, cookies, biscuits, scones, and pie crust. It is less suitable when you need a neutral color and flavor or the precise texture of solid shortening.
Option 2 Refined coconut oil
Why it works: Refined coconut oil is nearly all fat and can stay solid in a cool kitchen, so it behaves more like solid shortening than liquid oils do. Refined oil has little coconut flavor, while unrefined oil has a stronger coconut note.
Ratio: Use 1 cup, or 16 tablespoons, of coconut oil for every 1 cup of shortening. Use 1 tablespoon for every 1 tablespoon called for in a smaller recipe.
How to adjust: Melt and cool the oil for batters, but do not add it while hot. For pie dough, cut cold oil into the flour and let it soften only enough to work. Because coconut oil melts quickly, shaped cookies may spread; chill the dough before baking.
Best for: Cookies, brownies, muffins, cakes, and some pie crusts. Choose refined oil for a neutral result. It is less suitable when the recipe depends on a pronounced butter flavor.
Option 3 Neutral vegetable oil
Why it works: A neutral vegetable oil supplies the same main fat needed for a tender crumb and moist texture. It changes the recipe more than a solid fat because it cannot be creamed and adds no buttery flavor.
Ratio: Use 1 cup, or 16 tablespoons, of neutral oil for every 1 cup of shortening. For 1/2 cup of shortening, use 8 tablespoons of oil.
How to adjust: Measure the oil in a liquid measuring cup and mix it fully into the dry ingredients. Oil makes cookies more cakelike and spread more, so chill cookie dough. In cakes that depend on creaming, use the butter-and-oil blend instead. For greasing a pan, use only a thin coating rather than a recipe quantity.
Best for: Muffins, quick breads, brownies, and cakes. It is not the best choice for biscuits, laminated pastry, or a pie crust that needs solid fat for flakiness.
Option 4 Lard
Why it works: Plain lard is nearly all fat and gives dough a tender, flaky texture similar to that produced by shortening. It has little dairy flavor, but it can carry a mild pork note.
Ratio: Use 1 cup, or 16 tablespoons, of lard for every 1 cup of shortening. Keep it cold when measuring so it does not melt into the flour.
How to adjust: Cut cold lard into the flour, work the mixture just until the fat is evenly distributed, and chill doughs as directed. Lard melts readily, so cookie dough may need extra chilling. To soften the pork flavor, use 1/2 cup lard and 1/2 cup butter for each 1 cup of shortening.
Best for: Savory biscuits, scones, cobblers, and pie crust. It is less suitable for delicate vanilla cakes, candy, or frostings where its distinctive flavor would be noticeable.
Option 5 Butter-and-oil blend
Why it works: A blend combines some of the flavor and structure of butter with the tenderness and moisture of oil. It is useful when all-butter dough feels too rich or when all-oil batter lacks the texture you want.
Ratio: For every 1 cup of shortening, use 1/2 cup butter and 1/2 cup oil, or 8 tablespoons of each. For 1/2 cup shortening, use 4 tablespoons butter and 4 tablespoons oil.
How to adjust: Soften the butter and combine it with the oil. If the recipe calls for melted fats, melt both and cool them before mixing. The blend can make cookies spread more and cakes slightly less rich, so keep the original sugar and flour amounts for the first attempt. For pie dough, chill the blended fat until firm.
Best for: Cookies, muffins, cakes, biscuits, and pie crust. It works especially well when you want less butter flavor but still need more structure than liquid oil provides.
Option 6 Ghee
Why it works: Ghee is clarified butter with virtually no water and a higher proportion of fat than regular butter. That makes it closer to shortening in moisture and melting behavior, while retaining a buttery, slightly nutty flavor.
Ratio: Use 1 cup, or 16 tablespoons, of ghee for every 1 cup of shortening. Measure it as a liquid after warming, or scoop it into the measuring cup while soft.
How to adjust: Melt ghee for warm batters and allow it to cool before mixing. Ghee browns quickly, so watch cookies and pastry during the final minutes of baking. Because it softens quickly, chill cookie dough if the shaped cookies begin to spread.
Best for: Cookies, shortbread, flatbreads, and savory pastries. It is less suitable when a recipe specifically needs the water or full milk flavor of standard butter.
Option 7 Olive oil
Why it works: Olive oil provides fat for a tender, moist crumb and works particularly well in fruit-forward and rustic baked goods. Refined olive oil has a mild flavor, while extra-virgin olive oil has a fruitier, pepperier character.
Ratio: Use 1 cup, or 16 tablespoons, of olive oil for every 1 cup of shortening. Use the same volume measurement even when the oil appears thinner than the original fat.
How to adjust: Use refined olive oil when the recipe calls for a neutral fat. Mix the oil thoroughly into the batter, and do not try to cream it. Cookies will usually be more cakelike and spread more; chill the dough when necessary. Reduce the oil slightly only if the dough or batter becomes greasy, not because it seems different in color.
Best for: Olive oil cakes, fruit cakes, quick breads, and rustic breads. It is less suitable for pie crust or shortbread when you need solid-fat layers or buttery flavor.
Option 8 Avocado oil
Why it works: Refined avocado oil has a light color and mild flavor, so it can replace neutral shortening without changing the taste noticeably. It remains liquid, so it affects structure in the same way as other oils.
Ratio: Use 1 cup, or 16 tablespoons, of avocado oil for every 1 cup of shortening. For 1/2 cup shortening, measure 8 tablespoons of oil.
How to adjust: Mix the oil fully into the batter and do not expect it to cream with sugar. Cookies may spread and develop a more cakelike texture, so chill the dough before baking. For pan cooking, choose an oil whose label identifies it as suitable for the intended heat.
Best for: Cakes, muffins, quick breads, cookies, and pan cooking. It is not ideal for laminated dough, pie crust, or candy that depends on a firm, water-free fat.
Substitutes compared
| Substitute | Ratio | Best for | How the flavor changes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Unsalted butter | 1 cup per 1 cup | Cakes, cookies, biscuits, pie crust | Adds dairy flavor, richer browning, and more spread |
| Refined coconut oil | 1 cup per 1 cup | Cookies, brownies, muffins, cakes | Neutral when refined; unrefined adds a coconut note |
| Neutral vegetable oil | 1 cup per 1 cup | Muffins, quick breads, cakes, brownies | Little flavor change; adds a cakier texture and less structure |
| Lard | 1 cup per 1 cup | Savory biscuits, scones, pie crust | Adds a mild pork note and no dairy flavor |
| Butter-and-oil blend | 1/2 cup each per 1 cup | Cookies, muffins, cakes, pie crust | Retains some dairy flavor with a neutral oil |
| Ghee | 1 cup per 1 cup | Cookies, shortbread, flatbreads | Adds a buttery, slightly nutty note and browns quickly |
| Olive oil | 1 cup per 1 cup | Olive oil cakes, fruit cakes, quick breads | Adds a fruity or peppery note; refined oil is milder |
| Avocado oil | 1 cup per 1 cup | Cakes, muffins, cookies, pan cooking | Usually neutral; changes creaming and spread |
When not to substitute
- Laminated or puff pastry: These doughs depend on precise, even fat layers. Butter, coconut oil, and lard behave differently from shortening during rolling, folding, and baking.
- Pie or biscuit dough with liquid oil as the only fat: Oil changes tenderness and does not produce the same flaky layers. Use a solid fat or the butter-and-oil blend instead.
- Candy or frosting tied to a specific formula: Some mixtures depend on the water, milk solids, flavor, or browning of the stated fat. Changing it can alter the texture even when the volume is correct.
- Frying where fat behavior matters: The coating, flavor, and heat tolerance of solid shortening may be important. Use an oil specifically suited to that cooking method rather than assuming every baking oil is interchangeable.
- A recipe written for a specific fat profile: If the original formula is dairy-free or pork-free, check every replacement. Butter, ghee, and lard would break that formula.
Do not force the swap: If the fat supplies an essential structural role and the substitute changes flavor, spread, or layers too much, use shortening or revise the whole recipe rather than guessing.
Mistakes to avoid
- Measuring fat inconsistently: Use a standard cup and level it unless the recipe specifically says to pack the shortening. Do not use a loose spoon for a cup measurement or alternate between weight and volume.
- Changing several ingredients at once: Reducing sugar, changing flour, or adding extra leavening along with the fat makes it difficult to identify what changed the result.
- Ignoring the fat’s temperature: Soft fat cannot be creamed properly, while melted fat does not have the structure needed for some cookies and pastries. Follow the recipe’s softened or melted state.
- Using a strong flavor in a minor role: Lard, extra-virgin olive oil, and unrefined coconut oil can overpower a frosting or delicate cake that uses shortening only for texture.
- Failing to adjust for spread or browning: Butter and oil often spread more than shortening, while dairy fat can brown quickly. Measure the flour accurately, chill cookie dough, and watch the edges during baking.
How to store it so you have it next time
Keep shortening in its original container, tightly closed, in a cool, dark cabinet away from the stove. Keep butter, ghee, and lard sealed in the refrigerator at 40°F or below. You can freeze butter or lard in airtight portions for longer storage; thaw it in the refrigerator before measuring. Store coconut oil and vegetable oils in sealed containers away from heat and light, and follow the package directions.
Storage life changes with the formulation, package, and whether the container has been opened, so follow the package date and check the USDA FoodKeeper app or database rather than relying on one universal estimate. Date an opened bottle of oil so you can rotate it. Discard shortening or oil that smells stale or rancid, and throw out any fat showing mold or an unusual change in color or texture.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best substitute for shortening?
Unsalted butter is the most versatile substitute for most home baking. Use 1 cup of butter for 1 cup of shortening, then expect more flavor and spread. Refined coconut oil or neutral vegetable oil is a better choice when you want less butter flavor.
Can I use butter instead of shortening without changing the rest of the recipe?
Usually, yes. Keep the flour, sugar, and leavening unchanged for the first attempt, and use unsalted butter unless you adjust the salt. If cookie dough spreads too much, chill it before baking.
What is the best shortening substitute for cookies?
Unsalted butter works for most cookies, while refined coconut oil gives a more neutral flavor. A half-butter, half-oil blend also works when you want less richness. All three use a 1:1 volume ratio unless the recipe provides another instruction.
Can coconut oil replace shortening one for one?
Yes, use 1 cup of coconut oil for every 1 cup of shortening. Melt and cool it for batters, and let it soften just enough to work in pie dough. Refined oil has less coconut flavor, while unrefined oil will be more noticeable.
Can I use vegetable oil in pie crust?
Use a butter-and-oil blend rather than oil alone: 1/2 cup butter and 1/2 cup oil for each 1 cup of shortening. Mix the fat into the flour and chill the dough until firm. Oil alone changes the tenderness and flakiness.
How do I store shortening and substitute fats?
Keep shortening and vegetable oils sealed in a cool, dark place, and keep butter, ghee, and lard refrigerated at 40°F or below. Storage times vary by product, so check the package and the USDA FoodKeeper app or database. Discard fat that smells rancid or shows mold.
What this guide is based on
- Manufacturer use-and-care and support documentation for the device
Revision history
- Updated and re-checked against sources.
- First published.
Did this fix it?
Thanks. Glad it's sorted.
Sorry it's still not right. Recheck the symptom checker above, or tell us what you're seeing.